MaterialsMaterialsLab

GaAs vs Silicon vs GaN: The Semiconductor Designer's Picking Guide

When to use gallium arsenide, when silicon is fine, and why GaN is taking over power electronics. Band gap, efficiency, cost — explained without a physics degree.

Ryan Bethencourt
April 19, 2026
9 min read

Three semiconductors, three jobs

If you're designing circuits in 2026, you're probably using one of three semiconductors: silicon (Si), gallium arsenide (GaAs), or gallium nitride (GaN). Each wins a different category, and the question is almost never which is \"best\" — it's which is right for your voltage, frequency, and cost budget.

Tip
Quick rule: Silicon for anything under 100 V and under 3 GHz. GaN for power electronics above 100 V or switching faster than 1 MHz. GaAs for RF above 3 GHz and high-efficiency LEDs.

The three numbers that actually matter

  • Band gap — how much energy it takes to move an electron from valence to conduction band. Si: 1.1 eV, GaAs: 1.4 eV, GaN: 3.4 eV. Wider band gap = handle more voltage before breakdown.
  • Electron mobility — how fast electrons actually move. GaAs: 8,500 cm²/V·s, Si: 1,400, GaN: 2,000 (but 2D gas is ~2,200 in HEMT structures).
  • Thermal conductivity — how well heat leaves the chip. Si: 150 W/m·K, GaN: 130, GaAs: 55. (SiC, for comparison: 490 — the highest of common semiconductors, which is why it dominates high-power inverters.)

Silicon (Si): the default for a reason

Silicon's position isn't about performance — GaAs and GaN beat it on many metrics. It's about manufacturing. Silicon wafers are mature to 300 mm diameter, yield is 99%+, and the entire world's semiconductor fab capacity optimizes for it. A silicon logic chip costs pennies per transistor. GaN and GaAs are orders of magnitude more expensive.

Use silicon for: logic (CPUs, memory, FPGAs), power electronics under 100 V, audio and lower-frequency RF, MEMS, image sensors (CMOS).

GaAs: where speed pays

GaAs has electron mobility 6× silicon's. That translates to much faster switching — up to 100 GHz in modern HBT transistors. Where that actually matters:

  • Cellular basestation power amplifiers (up to ~40 GHz for 5G mmWave).
  • Satellite transceivers.
  • Radar frontends.
  • High-efficiency photovoltaic cells (up to 30% single-junction, vs ~22% for silicon — but 10× the price).
  • Infrared and red LEDs (AlGaAs).

Downsides: brittle (GaAs wafers are fragile), expensive (4× silicon), thermally poor (heat dissipates slowly). You don't use it unless RF performance demands it.

GaN: the power-electronics disruptor

Wide band gap means GaN devices can hold off much higher voltages in smaller die areas, and switch faster without breaking. The math:

  • A 650 V GaN switch is ~1/5 the size of a 650 V silicon MOSFET.
  • Switching losses are 3–10× lower.
  • Switching frequency can be 1–10 MHz (vs ~200 kHz for silicon).

That's why a GaN phone charger fits 100 W in a pocket. And why data-center power supplies, EV onboard chargers, and solar inverters are all moving GaN. The premium is real — GaN devices cost 2–4× silicon — but the system savings (smaller heatsinks, smaller inductors, less PCB area) more than pay it back above 100 W.

The 2026 semiconductor picking chart

  • CPU, GPU, RAM: Silicon. Forever.
  • Power management (under 100 V): Silicon.
  • Laptop / phone charger (100–300 W): GaN.
  • EV onboard charger (600–800 V): GaN or SiC.
  • EV drive inverter (800 V+): SiC.
  • Solar inverter: SiC or GaN.
  • 5G base station RF (28 GHz): GaAs or GaN.
  • Satellite transceiver: GaAs.
  • Radar (3–100 GHz): GaAs or GaN.
  • Red / infrared LED: AlGaAs or AlGaInP.
  • Blue / white LED: GaN (InGaN).
  • Efficient photovoltaic (space satellite): GaAs multi-junction.
  • Ground-mount solar farm: Silicon — price wins.

Look them up side by side

MaterialsLab has Si, GaAs, and GaN with crystal system, density, and band gap. Use compare mode to see all three at once. Free, no card.

Frequently Asked Questions

What's a wide band gap semiconductor?

Silicon has a band gap of ~1.1 eV. GaN (3.4 eV) and SiC (3.3 eV) are "wide band gap" — they need more energy to excite electrons, which means they can hold off higher voltages before breakdown. That's why they dominate high-voltage, high-frequency, and high-temperature power electronics.

Why is GaAs still used if silicon is cheaper?

Electrons move through GaAs about 6× faster than through silicon (electron mobility 8,500 vs 1,400 cm²/V·s). For RF applications above ~3 GHz, silicon just isn't fast enough. That's why cellular base stations, satellite transceivers, and radar amplifiers use GaAs.

Is GaN replacing silicon?

In power electronics above 600 V, yes. GaN chargers fit 100W in a pocket because they switch 10× faster than silicon and waste 3× less heat. In low-voltage logic (CPUs, DRAM) silicon still wins on cost and manufacturing maturity. Wide-bandgap displaces silicon only where the performance gain justifies the ~3× premium.

What about SiC?

Silicon carbide (SiC) is GaN's cousin for even higher voltage (>1,000 V). Tesla's inverter uses SiC; GaN is common in 100–600 V chargers and DC-DC converters. The split: SiC above ~1 kV, GaN from 100 V to 1 kV, silicon below 100 V.

Which LED material emits which color?

Blue LEDs need a band gap around 2.7 eV (wavelength ~460 nm). GaN delivers that — and coat it with phosphor and you get white LEDs. Green is also GaN (InGaN). Red is usually AlGaAs or AlGaInP. Infrared (1550 nm for fiber) is InGaAsP. One compound rarely does all the colors.

Run this yourself — no GPU, no install

Free for researchers. Pick a tool, paste your input, see results in seconds.